The Greenhorn
Many still believe that Langdon got his start in pictures with Mack Sennett, or - as the Old Man himself liked to say - that he came to Sennett direct from "the knockabout stage," "with no money and no fame" and (it was certainly implied) no moviemaking experience. Nothing could be farther from the truth!
In early 1923, when Harry Langdon was a big-time vaudeville headliner (with both money and fame), he decided to get into pictures. According to Harold Lloyd, who had seen the Langdons' act in Los Angeles, Harry spoke first with Hal Roach, but Roach wouldn't meet his price. He then turned, not to Sennett, but to wunderkind movie mogul Sol Lesser, signing a contract with Principal Pictures. Through the summer and early fall of 1923, Langdon cut his celluloid teeth as the star in an uncertain number of two-reel comedy shorts - there were at least three, The Sky Scraper (aka The Greenhorn), A Tough Tenderfoot, and A Perfect Nuisance, all directed by Alf Goulding. These films were not just planned, but actually made: the "Exhibitors Herald" was full of news about them at the time, and years later, two of the three - renamed Horace Greely Jr. and The White Wing's Bride - were released and distributed by Pathé.


The Cat's Meow
In October 1923, a general crisis of confidence among the major filmmakers, and possibly financial problems at Principal, resulted in a shakeup; Langdon found himself traded off, his contract snapped up by Sennett. But when Harry signed with Mack in November 1923, he was no obscure vaudeville trouper fresh from the tank towns. Rather, he was a much-ballyhooed Hollywood veteran who'd sweated under the hot sun on a movie lot, going through his paces in take after take. He'd earned respect, and he got it. Sennett gave his new acquisition great latitude, time to find his own style, his own team to craft his shorts, even (alone of all the comics on the lot) an orchestra to set the right mood during shooting. The Old Man expected great things of Harry.
The first short film Langdon made for Sennett, Smile Please, had been intended for another player; it's been suggested, with some truth, that any comic on the lot could have done as well as Harry did in this mish-mash of special-effect gags - only in the second reel, where Langdon is a harried photographer struggling to get an unprepossessing family's portrait taken, does the pace slow enough for him to work his magic. It was much the same with the next few pictures; Harry was all but smothered under the weight of tired gags, out-of-control plots, situations better suited to other comedians (in Picking Peaches he clings to a ladder, Lloyd-like, high above the city streets), and Sennett bathing beauties.
Somewhere around The First Hundred Years and The Luck o' the Foolish (August-September 1924), things began to change: the pace slowed, the stories became more coherent, and the focus was squarely on Harry's unique character with all his timid hesitancies and naïve responses. What made the difference? In part, it may have been the direction. From The Luck o' the Foolish on, Harry Edwards directed every one of Langdon's remaining films for Sennett. Maybe it was partly the consistency that came with gradual formation of a "Langdon team." Rounding out that team were Arthur Ripley, listed in the credits beginning with Boobs in the Wood (February 1925), and Frank Capra, beginning with Plain Clothes (March 1925). And maybe it was just a matter of Langdon finding his film legs.
Harry's popularity grew with each succeeding short, and the team began producing longer comedies, including three-reelers like There He Goes and Soldier Man. All the great comics of the era - among them Chaplin, Arbuckle, Normand, Lloyd, and Keaton - had made the transition to feature-length pictures, and now Langdon was running to catch up. With His First Flame, he did so (though it was not released immediately). In just two years on the Sennett lot, he'd vaulted to the top ranks of silent comedy stardom.

 

Part I

Part II

Part III

Part IV